Sagum

8+ years growing brands on KPIs, now with AI

Injury Attorney Marketing Judged by Signed Cases

We build injury attorney campaigns around cost per signed case, not cost per click, so your intake pipeline stays full.

8+ years growing service businesses on Google Ads, Meta, and TikTok

Google Ads PartnerMeta Ads PartnerTikTok Marketing Partner

Get your free marketing audit

Senior strategist review · response within one business day

No obligation. We'll only reach out about your strategy session.

Prefer to reach out directly?

The Challenge

Personal Injury Marketing Is Not Like Other Legal Advertising

Your best cases come from someone who just left the ER, got lowballed by an adjuster, or watched their car towed. Within hours they search 'car accident lawyer near me' and hire one of the first firms to answer the phone.

Lead-response research (InsideSales/MIT, 2007) found web leads called within five minutes were far likelier to qualify than those called half an hour later; every minute past five cuts your odds of signing the case, and after an hour they collapse.

Personal injury CPCs in a competitive metro routinely run $150 to $250, and one percentage point of intake conversion is worth tens of thousands of dollars in yearly contingency fees.

You also face TV incumbents with eight-figure ad budgets, shared lead vendors selling one inquiry to several firms, legal directories with unpredictable volume, and Google AI Overviews competing with paid ads on queries that used to convert best. Winning firms hold every dollar accountable to cost per signed case (CPSC).

The reality of marketing a Injury Attorneys business

The Opportunity

Top PI Firms Sign Far More Cases From the Same Leads

The average personal injury (PI) firm converts a small share of inquiries into signed retainers; top firms sign far more from the same leads. That gap is a fixable marketing and intake problem, not a case-quality problem.

At a standard 33% contingency, the average PI settlement of roughly $55,000 yields around $18,000 in fees. A trucking case backed by seven-figure commercial policies can settle for $100,000 to $1 million, yielding $33,000 to $330,000 in fees. An acquisition cost that hurts on a minor fender-bender is rational for a catastrophic injury, if your campaigns separate case types and bid accordingly.

Firms signing the most cases, not necessarily the biggest spenders, have the tightest keyword-to-landing-page match, fastest intake, and clearest attribution from first click to signed retainer. Few PI firms have all three, which leaves room for a disciplined operator.

What Most Get Wrong

What Most PI Firms and Their Agencies Get Wrong

  • Optimizing for calls instead of signed cases

    Your agency's dashboard counts property-damage-only calls, uninsured pedestrians with no liable party, and out-of-county callers as leads while the docket stays thin. Most agencies never report CPSC.

  • Running one campaign across all case types and geographies

    'Car accident lawyer Chicago' and 'car accident lawyer Peoria' are separate auctions with different CPCs, case values, and Quality Scores. Mixing them, or trucking with slip and fall, burns budget.

  • Letting low Quality Score add 50 to 70% to CPCs

    At Quality Score 3, a $200 market CPC becomes $334; a competitor at 8 pays $124. Most agencies never fix the causes: weak ad relevance and off-intent landing pages.

  • No 24/7 intake or slow response to new inquiries

    By your 9 a.m. callback, an 11 p.m. form lead has spoken with two firms. A missed 2 a.m. trucking call can hand a competitor one of your largest fees.

  • Buying shared vendor leads as your primary channel

    Shared leads convert at a fraction of an exclusive Search call's rate, and intake chases people signed elsewhere. They can supplement volume; build on them and you're renting your docket.

Why Now

AI Overviews Reshape Paid Clicks, and Summer Accident Season Raises PI CPCs

Ads earn lower click-through rates on results with an AI Overview than without one: about 16% vs 22% (Seer Interactive, through February 2026). Firms leading on landing-page conversion, Local Services Ads, and case-type targeting will turn more clicks into signed cases.

Most PI firms run set-and-forget campaigns built three years ago: static copy, no creative testing, no intake attribution. Using AI now to test ad angles faster, catch attribution gaps, and find the lowest-CPSC case types and geographies can build a structural advantage before summer.

Memorial Day through Labor Day is peak auto accident season in most markets, and CPCs spike as every competitor raises spend. Firms that optimize first enter the surge with better Quality Scores, higher conversion, and lower CPCs; mid-peak changes cost more and carry more risk.

The Mechanism

How AI Gives Personal Injury Firms a Real Edge

Real productivity, not AI theater. Here's where it actually moves a number for injury attorneys.

01

Digital Ads

What AI does: Assists with bid management and Quality Score across case-type campaigns, shifting budget each week toward the geographies and case types with the lowest CPSC.

The result: Budget follows signed-case performance instead of a static monthly allocation, so spend concentrates on campaigns producing retainers.

Why it matters here: At $150 to $250 CPCs, bid gains compound, and a campaign left on autopilot for a month bleeds budget on broad-match clicks.

02

Analytics and Attribution

What AI does: Connects the first click to the intake call, consultation, and signed retainer in your case management system, so every campaign is judged on CPSC.

The result: You see, by campaign and keyword, which case types and geographies produce profitable signed cases and which produce expensive calls that never convert.

Why it matters here: The average PI firm has no line of sight from a Google click to a signed retainer, so every budget decision is a guess.

03

Conversion Optimization

What AI does: Builds case-type landing pages for phone calls and form submissions, then continuously tests headlines, trust signals, and call-to-action placement against intake conversion data.

The result: Higher landing-page conversion means more calls from the same ad spend, directly lowering CPSC without a larger budget.

Why it matters here: A trucking page should look nothing like a slip and fall page, because buyer intent, damages range, competitive set, and trust signals all differ.

04

Creative

What AI does: Generates and tests ad copy variations across case types, trying urgency angles (statute of limitations, free consultation, no fee unless you win), social proof formats, and case-outcome framings within bar advertising rules.

The result: Testing five to ten variations per case type per month, versus one or two, surfaces the call-driving message faster so you can retire underperformers.

Why it matters here: State bar rules limit testimonials, past results, and solicitation language. Testing compliant variations at volume produces better-performing ads, with less bar-complaint risk than rushed one-offs.

How AI gives Injury Attorneys an edge

Ready to see what this looks like for your injury attorneys business?

No obligation. A senior strategist will show you exactly where the wins are.

The advertising strategy for a Injury Attorneys business

The Strategy

How PI Marketing Should Be Built and Run

Build on Google Search Ads and Local Services Ads (LSAs), with a separate campaign, landing page, and bid strategy for each case type: auto, truck, motorcycle, slip and fall, wrongful death. Split geographies down to the county in competitive markets, so Chicago and Peoria never share an auction.

LSAs come first where you qualify. They sit above Search Ads, carry the trust of a Google Verified badge, and with pay-per-lead pricing are the most efficient top-of-funnel channel for most PI firms in most markets. Verification (background checks, bar license) and review volume, which feeds ranking, are prerequisites.

Treat intake as marketing: track and record calls on every campaign and landing page, review them for intake quality, and monitor response time targets. Every minute past five cuts the odds of signing the case, so build 24/7 answering before launch.

Where platform policy allows, continuously retarget people who visited a case-type landing page but didn't call; they're still deciding and still within the statute of limitations window. Display and video ads that reinforce your reviews, the free consultation, and bar-compliant contingency-fee messaging recover some cases otherwise lost.

Cost per lead (CPL) is a leading indicator; CPSC is the scoreboard. Monthly reporting ties spend to intake volume, consultation rate, and signed retainers.

The one number that governs this

CPSC is the governing KPI: every campaign, landing page, and intake protocol is optimized against it, not calls or clicks.

How We Help

How We Run PI Campaigns and Intake for Your Firm

We start with attribution and intake so you can see the path from click to signed retainer, then run every campaign against your CPSC target.

Paid Search and Local Services Ads

We build separate campaigns by case type and geography, manage Quality Score to keep CPCs competitive, and shift budget weekly toward the lowest CPSC.

Analytics and Intake Attribution

We track calls on every campaign, connect intake to your case management system where possible, and report CPSC and intake conversion by campaign.

Case-Type Landing Pages and Conversion Optimization

We build a dedicated landing page for each case type, optimized for calls and bar-compliant trust signals, and test each against intake conversion data continuously.

Ad Creative and Copy Testing

Each month we test multiple copy variations per case type within state bar advertising rules to find the messages that drive calls.

Retargeting

Where platform policy allows, we retarget non-converting visitors with bar-compliant display and video ads to close cases still in the decision window.

AI Systems and Reporting

We build AI-assisted reporting that tracks CPSC by case type and geography, flags Quality Score decline before it gets expensive, and spots intake conversion gaps.

Who's Behind This

Who we are, and what makes us different

Sagum is a performance marketing agency founded in January 2017 in St. George, Utah. We've spent 8+ years growing real brands and being judged on KPIs, not vanity metrics.

We deliberately limit how many clients we take so each one gets senior attention. We treat your numbers like our own, we never run generic playbooks, and your strategy is built for your business, because shouldn't your brand's marketing be custom to your brand?

Sagum.ai is our AI arm: the same proven operators now build AI into the work wherever it creates real edge, not as theater, but as leverage applied with discipline.

  • 8+ years growing brands on performance KPIs, not vanity metrics
  • Limited client roster, with senior attention on every account
  • An extension of your team; your success is tied to ours
  • Custom strategy per brand, never a generic playbook
  • AI built in where it moves a number; judgment over hype

“Sagum is a performance marketing agency that's spent 8+ years growing brands by treating their numbers like our own. We take on few clients, never run generic playbooks, and now build AI into the work wherever it creates real edge, not hype. Your strategy is built for your business, and our success is tied to yours.”

The Sagum team, senior operators behind the strategy
“After six years, Sagum is our most important partner: trusted, communicative, and caring about our business as if it's their own.”

Long-term partner

6-year client

Proof

From a $20 CPL goal to $13 CPL and 300+ leads/mo

Rizzoli's Automotive

Challenge

Rizzoli's Automotive set a goal of 100 qualified leads per month at roughly $20 per lead.

What we did

We built a custom, call-driving landing page and rebuilt paid search around high-intent service queries. We'd take the same intent-matched approach to your firm's signed-case economics.

Result

Cost per lead came in at $13 against the $20 goal, monthly leads topped 300, and landing-page conversion exceeded 60%. The client opened multiple new locations.

Rizzoli's Automotive results
Cost per lead
$13
Leads / month
300+
Landing-page conversion
60%+
See more results at sagum.com/case-studies →

Find Out What Your Signed Cases Are Costing You

No obligation. For your firm, case types, and markets, we review your campaigns, intake attribution, and CPSC benchmark, and show you specifically where the gaps are.

Google Ads PartnerMeta Ads PartnerTikTok Marketing Partner

Sagum · January 2017 · St. George, Utah · 8+ years

TextCall
Personal Injury Law Firm Marketing | Sagum.ai · Sagum.ai